Home Carousel Archives - Anthrotech https://anthrotech.net/category/home-carousel/ Human dimensions for design solutions Thu, 06 Aug 2026 19:35:37 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.4 Value of Early Fit Testing and the Concept-of-Fit (COF) https://anthrotech.net/2026/08/06/value-of-early-fit-testing-and-the-concept-of-fit-cof/ Thu, 06 Aug 2026 19:35:37 +0000 https://anthrotech.net/?p=2103 Fit tests are structured, systematic methods to determine the range of fit in a size and compare design alternatives against... read more

The post Value of Early Fit Testing and the Concept-of-Fit (COF) appeared first on Anthrotech.

]]>
Fit tests are structured, systematic methods to determine the range of fit in a size and compare design alternatives against a defined set of criteria, referred to as the Concept-of-Fit (COF). They turn subjective preference into a transparent, auditable process that reduces risk, improves design, and increases stakeholder confidence. Early fit studies are cheap insurance against expensive mistakes. They maximize your ability to influence the project outcome with minimal investment, leading to better-performing, lower-risk, and more cost-effective products.
Some people have argued that fit testing does not work, because the subjects can’t tell us what fits and what does not in a consistent manner. It is true that subjects are not good at determining fit. That is why we don’t let them define it. We might ask subjects to rate the discomfort or the look, but we don’t let them decide if it fits. We develop, document, and agree upon how the product should fit, what constitutes a good fit versus a poor fit, and methods for assessing or measuring it. This is called the COF. (Robinette et al 2025) The COF also defines which conflicting aspects have priority or are essential. For example, if a coverall is comfortable and functions well but makes the person look sloppy or fat is that acceptable? If a head wearable is very comfortable, but it interferes with other equipment how much interference is acceptable? Finally, it builds stakeholder consensus with an objective, documented rationale.

For new products it is important to begin fit testing early in the product development process for several reasons:

1.Design Freedom is Highest Early On

          Early phases have the broadest set of possible alternatives. As the project progresses, decisions “freeze" the baseline. Changing direction later becomes exponentially more difficult and expensive. Early tests explore the full trade space before committing to a specific path.

          2.Cost of Changes Rises Dramatically Later

          This is one of the most cited principles in systems engineering (often shown as the “cost of change curve"). Late fit testing can result in the need to rework, retrofit, or to lose sales.  Locking in suboptimal designs or sizes can become painful (or impossible) to fix later.

          3.Requirements Are Still Flexible

            Early fit tests help balance and refine requirements themselves. They reveal which requirements drive cost, risk, or complexity the most, allowing intelligent trades (e.g., relaxing a performance requirement slightly to reduce number of sizes needed).

            4.Resource Efficiency

            Early tests prevent wasting effort on design concepts or sizes that would ultimately fail. They focus subsequent engineering work on the most promising path.

            5.Size Optimization

            With early fit testing we determine the range-of-fit in at least one size, and who we are fitting versus who we are not fitting. This permits us to optimize our sizing for our targeted population, remove unnecessary sizes, reduce redundancy, include sizes where the population is concentrated, and produce the right amount of each size.

            More information on fit testing and the COF can be found in  Robinette, K.M., Veitch, D., Alemany, S., & Bredenkamp, K. (2025). Product Fit and Sizing: Sustainable Product Evaluation, Engineering, and Design (1st ed.). CRC Press. https://www.routledge.com/Product-Fit-and-Sizing-Sustainable-Product-Evaluation-Engineering-and-Design/Robinette-Veitch-Alemany-Bredenkamp/p/book/9781032491189

            If you would like someone to help, Anthrotech provides this type of consulting service.

            The post Value of Early Fit Testing and the Concept-of-Fit (COF) appeared first on Anthrotech.

            ]]>
            2103
            Humans vs. Digital Models: Why Human Feedback Still Matters in Product Development https://anthrotech.net/2024/09/17/humans-vs-digital-models-why-human-feedback-still-matters-in-product-development/ Tue, 17 Sep 2024 22:51:19 +0000 https://anthrotech.net/?p=1999 In the fast-paced world of product development, Digital Human Models (DHMs) and CAD (Computer-Aided Design) systems are invaluable tools. They... read more

            The post Humans vs. Digital Models: Why Human Feedback Still Matters in Product Development appeared first on Anthrotech.

            ]]>
            In the fast-paced world of product development, Digital Human Models (DHMs) and CAD (Computer-Aided Design) systems are invaluable tools. They allow us to visualize, simulate, and design products efficiently. However, relying too heavily on these technologies without consulting actual people can be a costly mistake.

            While DHMs are great for getting us close to the desired design, they aren’t perfect, especially when it comes to accounting for the human experience. Here are a few real-life examples where human feedback revealed flaws that DHMs missed:


            1. “I know the computer model wears it that way, but I can’t. It won’t go there.”
              Just because it works for a digital model doesn’t mean it will work for a real person.
            2. “This either interferes with my utility belt or chokes me, or both, depending on where it is adjusted.”
              DHMs often miss situational complexities like how something interacts with other gear or accessories.
            3. “It feels like I’m in a tunnel, and it makes me uncomfortable or claustrophobic.”
              DHMs cannot replicate the psychological experiences or discomfort that people might feel when using a product.
            4. “Something is jabbing me in the back of the head.”
              An unnoticed adjustment clip caused discomfort for real users, something a DHM would never mention.
            5. “I can’t wear these. It’s fine standing up, but hurts when I sit or squat.”
              Fit and comfort vary depending on body position, a factor DHMs often fail to capture.
            6. “Well, the DHM may say I should see something, but I don’t.”
              Vision, perception, and body dynamics in real life can differ greatly from a computer simulation.
            7. “I feel stupid wearing this. You couldn’t pay me enough to wear this in public.”
              Human emotions and social factors—like how people feel wearing a product—are completely overlooked by DHMs.
            8. “It feels like it will fall off if I move too fast, and it makes me nervous.”
              Stability and confidence in wearing a product are critical, but DHMs won’t express anxiety or discomfort.
            9. “Yes, it slips a lot if I move too fast, but I like how it feels. The recommended size hurts.”
              Real feedback about sizing preferences can vary widely, something that CAD systems rarely accommodate.
            10. “It’s uncomfortable, but I’d still buy it because it makes me look good.”
              Style can outweigh comfort for some, a factor DHMs are unable to weigh in on.

            The takeaway? CAD systems and DHMs are great starting points, but they lack the ability to consider the psychological, emotional, and situational experiences of real users. Relying on these tools alone can lead to missed insights, costly design revisions, or even product failure.

            While technology continues to improve, there’s currently no digital solution capable of replicating the full human experience—especially when it comes to preferences, discomfort, or even fashion choices. A quick round of real-world testing can help avoid significant setbacks and ensure the product you deliver truly meets the needs of your customers.

            In some cases, as with examples 9 and 10, human feedback can even help you refine product sizes or avoid unnecessary variations, ultimately saving money and resources.

            Bottom line: DHMs are valuable, but never underestimate the importance of human feedback in product development. It’s the missing piece that bridges the gap between good design and great user experience.

            Interested for more in-depth information on this topic? Click here and send us a message requesting the latest on Cases and Fit Models.

            The post Humans vs. Digital Models: Why Human Feedback Still Matters in Product Development appeared first on Anthrotech.

            ]]>
            1999 //ffscdn.s3.us-east-1.amazonaws.com/anthrotech.net/2024/02/resources-keys-determine-fit.png